Jenkins Research Inc.
Jenkins Research Inc.
  • The Jenkins Research Advantage
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Public Opinion Reviews
    • Public Policy Public Opinion
    • Elections and electoral behaviour
  • Canadian Public Opinion Polls
Jenkins Research Inc.
  • The Jenkins Research Advantage
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Public Opinion Reviews
    • Public Policy Public Opinion
    • Elections and electoral behaviour
  • Canadian Public Opinion Polls
  • Home
  • Public Opinion
  • The Kind of Campaign that Makes You Think They Don’t Matter

The Kind of Campaign that Makes You Think They Don’t Matter

April 20, 2011 Written by Richard Jenkins

The poll results today (the definitive Nanos tracking) tell us that nothing has happened in this campaign. The parties remain in the same order and with almost the same share of decided voters as they did when the campaign was launched. As much as the media hang on every movement in the polls (and hope each perceived gaffe or new announcement produces such movement), this has — and will likely continue to be — a steady as you go campaign.

The small movements in the trends for each party over time are a combination of a real stimulus response reaction to news events and the sampling error that naturally occurs. We can construct a story for each rise and fall for the parties but in retrospect, it appears so far, that there has been little enduring impact of any of the campaign on voters.

Setting aside the fact that the national numbers could be masking significant riding-level changes, what are we to make of the campaign when it appears to be so little change? Is it really true that they don’t matter? Should we expect game-changing campaign events to fundamentally alter who wins on election day?

The reality is that a lack of movement does not necessarily mean that the campaign is irrelevant — it merely suggests that voters are not getting new information on which to revise their judgement . This either reflects a lack of new information or that people are not paying attention to the new information. Both of which are likely.

Thinking back to recent campaigns a number of dramatic movements occurred but in all cases these movements reflected an increase in information about something voters were likely unsure. In this campaign, there was little opportunity for a grand revelation that would fundamentally alter the party’s fortunes and, so far, this has proven correct. While Ignatieff had the greatest potential to surprise thanks to his pre-campaign image (helped by Conservative ads), there has not been a defining moment significant enough to cut through and reach significant voters.

The fact remains that to impact voters the new information much be dramatic and widely available because we know that (a) people ignore information that they disagree with and (b) seek out information that buttresses existing views.

One could argue that the modern election campaign is actually less likely to be the place to educate voters now compared with the past.  Current laws require that the minimum length of an election campaign at the federal level is 36 days and recent campaigns have generally been of this length. But 36 days is simply not enough time to tell people everything that parties and their leaders are trying to tell them.

A solution for parties is to break out of the idea that campaigning is for elections. Platforms — especially those of the opposition — need to be released months ahead of time. There is more time to talk about them, refine them, and, in a minority situation, define what it is to be that party.

Don’t be surprised if the campaign continues on its current track… new leaders, a great (or bad) new idea, or a dramatic change in turnout are what will make election campaigns more dynamic in the future.

Public Opinion
campaign, Canada, Canadian election 2011, polls, voting
Similar posts
  • More and more polling about non-policy issues | 2018 Q1 Publicly Released Polls — Twenty-four months ago, the database of public opinion releases that fuels this analysis was started. All this time later, information on 1762 releases has been compiled. Readers are reminded that more than one release might appear on a single survey data collection period. Below are some insights into this quarter’s information. Overall Number of Releases [...]
  • Year over year decline in number of publicly released polls in Canada — Q4 — While polling continued to be ubiquitous in Q4 (195 public opinion releases were identified), the number actually was significantly lower than in Q4 of 2016 when 259 polls were released (the quarterly tracking is here). Given the October to December period is a natural time for polling to surge as Parliament is sitting, the decline [...]
  • Public policy dominated Q3: A look at publicly released polls — Q3 saw an expected decline in the number of polls released into the public domain from Q2 as the summer broad less polling activity. This aligns well with the 2016 summer result. International trade and relations were top topics of national public policy polls as polling companies and the media turned their attention to NAFTA [...]
  • Implications of survey mode on public opinion content | a look at the number of questions — Survey mode is an interesting variable in the current market research industry landscape. Historically we moved from in-person to mail to telephone and online as the principle methods of polling. The latest entry into the survey mode toolkit is the IVR or interactive voice response survey. Several market research firms in Canada release polls into [...]
  • More election polls and fewer policy related polls in Q2 — Q2 saw a rise from Q1in the number of polls released into the public domain as 173 unique surveys produced 257 different releases compared with 195 in Q1. Overall, however, the number of polls is consistent with Q2 of 2016. More than half of these were national polls with provincial and local polls representing the [...]
MR for Small Business: The Challenge
Voting in Advanced Polls… Scepticism about its Meaning

Recent Posts

  • More and more polling about non-policy issues | 2018 Q1 Publicly Released Polls
  • Year over year decline in number of publicly released polls in Canada — Q4
  • PollingGuru.ca
  • Public policy dominated Q3: A look at publicly released polls
  • Implications of survey mode on public opinion content | a look at the number of questions

Topics

  • Company News
  • Consulting Business
  • Consumer and brand behaviour
  • Elections
  • Industry News and Trends
  • Public Opinion
    • Canadian Public Poll Analysis
  • Public Opinion Issue Review
  • Public Policy
  • Survey methodology
  • Uncategorized

Tags

analysis of public opinion apps Assisted dying brand campaign Canada Canadian election 2011 CCI Company News Consumer confidence customer satisfaction design economy election elections feature grocery health Industry trends Internet Jenkins Research market research methodology MRIA online panels policy polls public opinion public polls questionnaire science small business social marketing social media survey survey design survey questions tools trends turnout United States value change values wireless